| Year |
Regular Season Champ |
Tournament Champ |
Coach of the Year, Institution |
| 1969 |
Lynchburg |
no tournament |
Gerald Thomas, Lynchburg |
| 1970 |
Lynchburg |
no tournament |
|
| 1971 |
Lynchburg |
no tournament |
Gerald Thomas, Lynchburg |
| 1972 |
Methodist |
no tournament |
Bruce Shelley, Methodist |
| 1973 |
Lynchburg |
no tournament |
Gerald Thomas, Lynchburg |
| 1974 |
Virginia Wesleyan |
no tournament |
Steve Stocks, Virginia Wesleyan |
| 1975 |
Lynchburg |
no tournament |
Gerald Thomas, Lynchburg |
| 1976 |
Methodist |
no tournament |
|
| 1977 |
Methodist |
no tournament |
Bruce Shelley, Methodist |
| 1978 |
Virginia Wesleyan |
no tournament |
Towny Townsend, Virginia Wesleyan |
| 1979 |
Methodist |
no tournament |
Mark Bond, Methodist & Towny Townsend, Virginia Wesleyan |
| 1980 |
Methodist |
no tournament |
Tom Austin, Methodist & Tony Guzzo, N.C. Wesleyan |
| 1981 |
N.C. Wesleyan |
no tournament |
Tony Guzzo, N.C. Wesleyan |
| 1982 |
Methodist & N.C. Wesleyan |
no tournament |
Tom Austin, Methodist & Tony Guzzo, N.C. Wesleyan |
| 1983 |
N.C. Wesleyan |
no tournament |
Mike Fox, N.C. Wesleyan |
| 1984 |
N.C. Wesleyan |
no tournament |
Tom Austin, Methodist |
| 1985 |
N.C. Wesleyan |
no tournament |
Mike Fox, N.C. Wesleyan |
| 1986 |
Methodist |
no tournament |
Tom Austin, Methodist |
| 1987 |
N.C. Wesleyan |
no tournament |
Mike Fox, N.C. Wesleyan |
| 1988 |
N.C. Wesleyan |
no tournament |
Nick Boothe, Virgniia Wesleyan |
| 1989 |
Methodist |
no tournament |
Tom Austin, Methodist & Abe Naff, Ferrum |
| 1990 |
Ferrum, N.C. Wesleyan |
no tournament |
Howard Wiseman, Christopher Newport |
| 1991 |
N.C. Wesleyan |
no tournament |
Mike Fox, N.C. Wesleyan |
| 1992 |
Ferrum |
no tournament |
Abe Naff, Ferrum |
| 1993 |
Ferrum, N.C. Wesleyan |
no tournament |
Mike Fox, N.C. Wesleyan |
| 1994 |
N.C. Wesleyan |
N.C. Wesleyan |
Mike Fox, N.C. Wesleyan |
| 1995 |
Methodist |
N.C. Wesleyan |
Scott Rash, Greensboro |
| 1996 |
Methodist |
Methodist |
Tom Austin, Methodist |
| 1997 |
N.C. Wesleyan |
N.C. Wesleyan |
Mike Fox, N.C. Wesleyan |
| 1998 |
Methodist |
Greensboro |
Scott Rash, Greensboro & Tom Austin, Methodist |
| 1999 |
Methodist, Ferrum,
N.C. Wesleyan |
N.C. Wesleyan |
Charlie Long, N.C. Wesleyan |
| 2000 |
N.C. Wesleyan |
N.C. Wesleyan |
Paul O’Neil, Shenandoah |
| 2001 |
Methodist,
Christopher Newport |
Christopher Newport |
John Harvell, Christopher Newport |
| 2002 |
Methodist, Ferrum |
Christopher Newport |
Tom Austin, Methodist |
| 2003 |
Ferrum |
Averett |
Abe Naff, Ferrum |
| 2004 |
Ferrum |
Methodist |
Abe Naff, Ferrum |
| 2005 |
Methodist |
Ferrum |
Tom Austin, Methodist |
| 2006 |
Methodist |
N.C. Wesleyan |
Tom Austin, Methodist |
| 2007 |
Methodist,
N.C. Wesleyan, Ferrum |
Ferrum |
Ed Fulton, Averett |
| 2008 |
Christopher Newport |
Christopher Newport |
John Harvell, Christopher Newport |
| 2009 |
N.C. Wesleyan |
N.C. Wesleyan |
Charlie Long, N.C. Wesleyan |
| 2010 |
N.C. Wesleyan |
Shenandoah |
Charlie Long, N.C. Wesleyan |
| 2011 |
Shenandoah |
Christopher Newport |
Kevin Anderson, Shenandoah |
| 2012 |
Christopher Newport |
Christopher Newport |
John Harvell, Christopher Newport |
| 2013 |
Christopher Newport |
Methodist |
Charlie Long, N.C. Wesleyan |
| 2014 |
Covenant |
no tournament |
Ryan Brittle, Ferrum |
| 2015 |
Methodist |
no tournament |
Tom Austin, Methodist |
| 2016 |
Ferrum |
Huntingdon |
Ryan Brittle, Ferrum |
| 2017 |
LaGrange |
LaGrange |
David Kelton, LaGrange |
| 2018 |
Methodist |
LaGrange |
Tom Austin, Methodist |
| 2019 |
Piedmont |
LaGrange |
Justin Scali, Piedmont |
| 2020 |
Vacant (Season cancelled 3/16/20 due to Coronavirus outbreak) |
| 2021 |
East: N.C. Wesleyan
West: LaGrange |
LaGrange |
Greg Clifton, N.C. Wesleyan |
| 2022 |
East: N.C. Wesleyan
West: LaGrange |
LaGrange |
David Kelton, LaGrange |
| 2023 |
N.C. Wesleyan |
N.C. Wesleyan |
Greg Clifton, N.C. Wesleyan |
| 2024 |
N.C. Wesleyan |
N.C. Wesleyan |
Greg Clifton, N.C. Wesleyan |
| 2025 |
Methodist |
Methodist |
Tom Austin, Methodist |
| 2026 |
Greensboro |
Pfeiffer |
Chris Fenisey, Greensboro |